When it comes to healthy, natural treats for your dog, two superfoods always steal the spotlight, pumpkin and sweet potato. Both are tasty, nutritious, and dog-approved! 

But when comparing pumpkin vs sweet potato for dogs, which one comes out on top? Let’s dig in (pun intended!) and find out which super-snack is best for your four-legged friend.

Pumpkin For Dogs

Pumpkin is one of nature’s most paw-some ingredients for dogs.
It’s gentle on their tummy, low in calories, and packed with essential vitamins that support everything from digestion to shiny coats.

 Pumpkin benefits for dogs:

• High in fibre, great for digestion and stool regularity.

• Contains vitamins A, C, and E to boost immunity and eye health.

• Low in calories – ideal for weight management.

• Naturally hydrating thanks to its high water content.

• Full of antioxidants to support long-term health.

So if your dog ever has tummy troubles or needs a low-fat snack, pumpkin is a super soothing choice.

Sweet Potato For Dogs

Now let’s talk about sweet potato — pumpkin’s slightly sweeter cousin.
Sweet potatoes are full of slow-release carbs that give your dog a steady source of energy (without the sugar rush).

Sweet potato benefits for dogs:

• Rich in dietary fibre to keep digestion smooth.

• Contains vitamins B6 and C for healthy skin and strong immunity.

• Packed with potassium and manganese, which support heart and muscle health.

• Naturally sweet and satisfying, making them a great treat for picky eaters.

Sweet potato is also a brilliant gluten-free alternative to grains, making it ideal for sensitive or allergy-prone pups.

Pumpkin vs Sweet Potato for Dogs: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Which Is Better For Dogs, Pumpkin Or Sweet Potato?

When it comes to pumpkin vs sweet potato for dogs, both are superstar ingredients but the “better” one depends on your pup’s needs.

Choose pumpkin if your dog:

• Has a sensitive stomach

• Needs a low-calorie snack

• Could benefit from a hydration boost

Choose sweet potato if your dog:

• Needs more energy for playtime or walks

• Loves chewy, hearty treats

• Needs extra vitamins for coat and heart health

Or better yet… mix both!
A balanced variety of natural treats keeps your dog’s diet exciting, nutritious, and tail-waggingly good.

Shop Our Bestselling Pumpkin & Sweet Potato Dog Treats

Shop Carrot & Pumpkin Dog Treats

• Keeps dog's teeth clean & supports digestion
  

Shop Now

Shop Sweet Potato Dog Chews

• Packed with healthy vitamins for a happy tummy

Shop Now

Soopa’s Superfood Approach

At Soopa, we believe healthy should always mean tasty.
That’s why our Pumpkin & Carrot Dental Sticks and Sweet Potato Chews are made with 100% natural, human-grade ingredients — nothing artificial, no grains, and definitely no nasties.

Whether your dog loves the earthy sweetness of pumpkin or the chewy goodness of sweet potato, both options support digestion, immunity, and overall wellness.

Read Next:

• Can Pumpkin Help Dogs With Diarrhea? 

• Halloween Dog Treats Guide: Safe, Healthy & Fun Ideas

• 25+ Dog Halloween Costume Ideas Your Pup Will Love

• 5 Easy DIY Halloween Dog Treat Recipes (With a Soopa Twist!)

• The Health Benefits of Pumpkin for Dogs (and Why It’s a Soopa Superfood)

• Pumpkin vs Sweet Potato: Which Is Better for Dogs?